So here's a general list of the good and the bad so far:
Struggles
- I've found that starting my clarinets on C has been somewhat problematic as it has been difficult for many of them to make sure they've covering all three of the front keys on their left hand for this, so they're not quite as successful with their first notes. However, starting some of them on E has been much more successful, and it is easier from there to add a finger for D and then another for C.
- Similar situation for flutes, I started some on G but they're not all as successful as some that I've had start on B. The advantage to my position is that if I find something is not working in the first day or two of lessons during the week, I can adjust as the week goes on and the later lessons are more successful, and then I can help the early lessons fix things the following week.
- Teaching tonguing has been hit or miss with many of the groups. I've demonstrated and am really stressing no space between the notes so that the air is continuous. I have them start by saying "ta ta ta", and noticing how their tongues feel against the roof of their mouth and how quickly it just flicks against the roof (particularly for brass, though a similar concept obviously applies for the woodwinds, just against the reed for the saxes and clarinets instead of their teeth/gum line). I then have them take a deep breath and blow it out with the "too" articulation so that they see what it sounds and feels like with no space in between. I then have them apply it to their mouthpieces. I'd say about half of them get it no problem, while the other half I have to work with a bit (which I expect; I would be amazed if more of them got it immediately with no problem). It's mostly trying to make sure they keep the air going and are not letting their tongues suction to the roof of their mouths when they tongue. I've been using the whole "your air is like a stream of water" analogy, and luckily every room I've taught in so far has had a sink so I've been able to literally show them. That seems to help some students.
- Four of my flute players are just having the hardest time getting a sound out. I've done the watermelon seed spitting analogy, blowing over a bottle top, asked them to practice in the mirror, telling and showing them how much air they need to make a sound, adjust the flute on their mouth for them and help them experiment with rolling them in and out, etc... No matter what I do these students simply will not change what they're doing and I don't know what to do from here. One of them absolutely cannot get her flute in the middle of her mouth when she plays, another blows way to hard and can't make a small enough hole with her aperture, and the others don't use enough air. I'm hoping with the more specific information we went over in our lessons this week and another week of practice that they'll be more successful next week.
- To the contrary of my last bullet in the struggles category, the majority of my flutes are getting excellent sounds in their first lessons, and some can even play two octaves of the three notes we've learned! Yay! The analogies listed above have worked really well for these girls.
- Most of my trumpet players are getting C out as their first note but I do have a couple getting G out first. Although I know this is normal and perfectly fine to start, I was hoping since it's only two or three that are getting G I could possibly get them to play C to start instead so that everyone's learning the same notes together. One of them simply has not been able to play the C yet, but I've gotten the rest to play G with little struggle simply by demonstrating what happens to my chin when I buzz from a high note to a low note on the mouthpiece. It seems to be more effective than saying "you need to make the whole in your mouth bigger for low notes and think "ah" and warmer air, etc...".
- Being a little goofy/dramatic with some concepts. For example, for the trumpets I have them make a "claw" with their right hand to really exaggerate how curved their fingers should be when they play. Whenever I see them starting towards flat fingers I have them all give me a claw high in the air and then drop it onto their valves. I tell them right out that some of the things I teach I will purposely make goofy because things like that tend to stick better. I must admit, a high percentage of my trumpet players have come back with excellent hand position this week.
- Teaching trombones proper hand position by saying their left hand is like a squirt gun and their right hand is like a "spock" hand. Granted for the students who don't know the reference it's ok because most of them recognize the hand when I demonstrate it, and it's a great way to teach proper slide hand. Yay for a generation of trombone players who hold their slide correctly :)
- Percussion! After my college experience (or lack thereof) with percussion I thought for sure I'd be in major trouble for teaching percussion, but my senior student teaching set me up so well for this. Our percussionists here learn bells and snare, and I have some solid concepts that set them up well (or at least I think they will) to be successful, well-rounded percussionists. I'm trying to start them off with good habits and so far they've all caught on quite well (such as making sure their rebounds are small, posture is good, etc...). I just need to make sure I stay consistent with them.